— Begin quote from ____
BGP uploaded these maps to Imgur, and in order to do so, agreed to Imgur’s Terms of Service. The Imgur Terms of Service very clearly state that by uploading a file, a person grants to Imgur “a non-exclusive, royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable worldwide license (with sublicense and assignment rights) to use, to display online and in any present or future media, to create derivative works of, to allow downloads of, and/or distribute any such file or content.” The Imgur Terms of Service also very clearly state that by uploading a file, a person accepts that Imgur is using its irrevocable sublicense and assignment license to grant license to any person to use that content “for personal, non-commercial purposes.” The Imgur Terms of Service note that when a file is deleted, Imgur’s license does not expire (“irrevocable”), and “anything you post to a public portion of our site may be used by the public pursuant to the following paragraph even after you delete it.”
In short, whether he likes it or not, BGP granted all of us the continuing license to use his maps, provided we use them for “personal, non-commercial purposes.” I cannot think of a more personal, non-commercial use than role-playing on an online message board.
— End quote
— Begin quote from ____
— Begin quote from ____
— Begin quote from ____
I still have yet to hear anything from BGP about allowing me to edit it.
— End quote
— End quote
Maps are TEP property, go ahead and edit it since you are the cartographer around here. I’m sure Todd fully agrees.
Wrong.
These maps are the property of the original content developer, which is British Grand Pacific. You do not have permission to edit these maps without his permission.
I have had a discussion with him this evening, and if you would like permission to edit the map, please send a telegram to [nation]British Grand Pacific[/nation] in game.
-Raven
— End quote
After what FPS said, I’m more inclined to agree with him. Unless BGP had a tumblr or a personal website that explicitly said “No Distributing without permission.” He signed the agreement with Imgur, and it’s out there. If he doesn’t like it, tough luck.
Also, SY, how about giving it a time limit? If he doesn’t reply in a week, it’s fair game.